Best Amish Fireless Fireplace Reviews

Best Amish Fireless Fireplace Reviews

When choosing an electric fireplace, do not limit yourself to the standard wall mounted or firebox insert models. Another electric fireplace type that you can look into is the Amish electric fireplace.

As the name suggests, most of these electric fireplaces were developed with the help of Amish people. Amish communities, despite being known for their non-reliance on modern technology, are pretty adept when it comes to woodworking. Most Amish fireplace manufacturers employ them to exclusively craft the fireplace mantels.

On the other hand, the heater motor found on these units can either be imported from other countries like China or made within the United States. Brands like Heat Surge and Pleasant Hearth source their heating units from China while the technology behind the firebox screens are developed in-house.

With the ever-increasing number of electric fireplaces manufacturers, keeping tabs on which fireplace type and brand that you like can be difficult. To narrow down your choices, we’ve compiled the best Amish fireless fireplaces available in the market today.

  1. Pleasant Hearth GLF-5002-68 Sheridan Mobile Fireplace

The Sheridan Mobile Fireplace is one of’s better reviewed electric fireplaces. It is classified as an Amish fireplace primarily because of its elegant wooden mantel that comes in cherry and white colors.

Just like any electric fireplace, it does not emit real flames, fumes, or ashes. Its heat source is a 5200 BTU heater that can warm up a room that is 1,000 square feet in area. The firebox display is as realistic as any traditional hearth – sporting life-sized glowing logs and concrete bricks on the sides of the firebox. You can also choose between five heat levels and three flame intensity levels.

The entire fireplace weighs about 55 lbs but don’t worry since the unit has built-in wheels and you can transport it anywhere you like. If you are looking for a portable electric fireplace that can match to any room’s ambience, the Sheridan Mobile Fireplace is your best bet.

  1. Lifesmart Large Room Infrared Quartz Fireplace in Burnished Oak Finish

With an average of 4.3-stars (out of 600+ verified reviews) on, Lifesmart’s Large Room Infrared Quartz Fireplace is a bestseller among portable Amish-style electric fireplaces. Plus, the unit’s mantel has a burnished oak finish that makes it fitting to most living rooms.

Powered by a quartz infrared heater located at the top portion of the fireplace, the Lifesmart circulates heat using quiet blower fans and can warm up a 500 square feet room.

It also comes with a remote control where you can adjust the heat intensity and program the thermostat. Just like most electric fireplaces, you can turn on the fireplace display without using the heating mechanism. The entire unit is portable and comes with caster wheels.

If you want an affordable portable electric fireplace without sacrificing heating capacity, Lifesmart’s Large Room Infrared Quartz Fireplace is your best bet.

  1. Heat Surge Mini Mate Decorative Heater

Heat Surge’s Mini Mate Decorative Heater has all the trappings of a modern electric fireplace. It is still a portable Amish-style electric fireplace but in a much smaller size and perfect for smaller rooms and motor homes.

Since Heat Surge fireplace mantels are handcrafted by Amish craftsmen, the MiniMate is a special order item. If you purchase one at, product returns aren’t allowed. The mantels are made from real wood.

The MiniMate emits heat with the use of convection heating and can generate up to 3,685 BTUs enough for zone heating of small rooms. It also makes use of the company’s Heat Surge Cool Touch Vent and Fireless Flame technologies.

  1. Classic Flame 23IRM1500-O107 Rolling Mantel with Infrared Quartz Fireplace

Classic Flame’s Electric Fireplace is powered by an infrared quartz heater and its mantel is made from premium quality oak. What is great about this portable fireplace is its heating capacity. It generates up to 5200 BTUs and can heat up any room up to 1000 square feet in area. Most homeowners are drawn to this Classic Flame Amish fireplace because it is suitable for zone heating in most homes. With zone heating, homeowners can save on electricity bills since only occupied rooms are heated.

This unit is shipped with a ready-made mantel and furniture-quality wheels. It comes with a remote control where you can adjust the flame intensity and firebox display. You can even choose between five flame colors –Campfire, Spectrafire, Amethyst, Midnight Fire, and Sapphire, or random color.

  1. LifeSmart LifePro LS-1111HH Portable Infrared Quartz Fireplace Heater

The LifeSmart LifePro model LS-1111HH is another electric fireplace designed to heat up small spaces. Powered by an infrared quartz heater, it can generate up to 5100 BTUs and warm up rooms with an area up to 150 square feet. It is best used in addition to a home’s heating system, or in dorm rooms, garages, bedrooms, or small offices.

The entire unit has the following dimensions: Length: 30 inches x Height: 25.5 x Width: 13.5 inches. It comes with a battery-operated remote control where you can adjust the firebox display and flame settings.

The mantel is made of oak wood and comes already assembled when shipped. Most users find the flame display to be very realistic. Overall, this is a reasonably-priced unit that delivers consistent results.

Final Thoughts

So those are the top five Amish fireless fireplaces that you can choose from. If you want to level up your faux fireplace experience, you can also purchase an additional fire crackler sound system and aromatic incense candles. Hopefully, this list helps you make an informed choice so that you can select the best Amish fireplace for your home.

Leave a Reply